The Peltoncast Search for Seattle’s Best Sandwich

Our Choice for Seattle’s Best Sandwich

Ma’ono Fried Chicken

Locations: Capitol Hill, University Village, West Seattle
Reviewed on: Episode 152

Listener Choice for Seattle’s Best Sandwich

Other Coast Cafe

Locations: Ballard, Queen Anne
Reviewed on: Episode 151


Tristan’s rating: 94
Kevin’s rating: 98

Finalist

Tristan’s rating: 98
Kevin’s rating: 97

Tat’s Delicatessen

Location: Pioneer Square
Reviewed on: Episode 153


Tristan’s rating: 99
Kevin’s rating: 94
The Famous Cousin Katie’s rating: 95

Semifinalists

Salumi

Location: Pioneer Square
Reviewed on: Episode 162


Tristan’s rating: 92
Kevin’s rating: 95

Paseo

Location: Fremont, Sodo, T-Mobile Park
Reviewed on: Episode 171


Tristan’s rating: 90
Kevin’s rating: 95
Katie’s rating: 94

Other contenders

The Swinery

Location: West Seattle
Reviewed on: Episode 161


Tristan’s rating: 94
Kevin’s rating: 93

Sisters and Brothers

Location: Georgetown
Reviewed on: Episode 155


Tristan’s rating: 93
Kevin’s rating: 92

Marination

Locations: Alki, Capitol Hill, Denny Triangle
Reviewed on: Episode 160


Tristan’s rating: 92
Kevin’s rating: 93

Un Bien

Location: Ballard (2 locations)
Reviewed on: Episode 171


Tristan’s rating: 88
Kevin’s rating: 93
Katie’s rating: 93

Bok a Bok Fried Chicken and Biscuits

Locations: Burien, Capitol Hill, White Center
Reviewed on: Episode 153


Tristan’s rating: 90
Kevin’s rating: 90

Little Neon Taco

Location: Capitol Hill
Reviewed on: Episode 166


Tristan’s rating: 87
Kevin’s rating: 91

Tubs Gourmet Subs

Locations: Lake City, Lynnwood
Reviewed on: Episode 156

 

View this post on Instagram

 

The giant Texas Turkey at Tubs Gourmet Subs. Review on this week’s pod.

A post shared by The Fabulous Peltoncast (@peltoncast) on


Tristan’s rating: 88
Kevin’s rating: 88

Phorale

Location: Truck
Reviewed on: Episode 157

 

View this post on Instagram

 

The sun is out and so is this beautiful sandwich from @phoraleseattle

A post shared by The Fabulous Peltoncast (@peltoncast) on


Tristan’s rating: 93
Kevin’s rating: 81
The Famous Cousin Katie’s rating: 90

Sunset Fried Chicken

Location: Capitol Hill
Reviewed on: Episode 169


Tristan’s rating: 83
Kevin’s rating: 91

HoneyHole Sandwiches

Locations: Capitol Hill
Reviewed on: Episode 151


Tristan’s rating: 91
Kevin’s rating: 84

Elliott Bay Pizza Company and Flame Burger

Location: Queen Anne Hill
Reviewed on: Episode 158


Tristan’s rating: 80
Kevin’s rating: 89

Royal Grinders

Location: Fremont
Reviewed on: Episode 163

 

View this post on Instagram

 

The Royal Grinder at Royal Grinders in Fremont next to the Lenin statue. Review on this week’s pod – link in bio!

A post shared by The Fabulous Peltoncast (@peltoncast) on


Tristan’s rating: 80
Kevin’s rating: 87

Meat & Bread

Location: South Lake Union
Reviewed on: Episode 169


Tristan’s rating: 78
Kevin’s rating: 87

Cemitas Poblanas

Location: Boulevard Park
Reviewed on: Episode 164


Tristan’s rating: 70
Kevin’s rating: 85

Montlake Boulevard Market

Location: Montlake
Reviewed on: Episode 165


Tristan’s rating: 73
Kevin’s rating: 76