Seattle’s Best Tacos/Burrito
Tacos Chukis
Locations: Capitol Hill, Westlake, Beacon Hill
Reviewed on: Episode 98
Tristan says: “We can have on the same plate tacos and burritos, each of which are Seattle’s best.”
Tristan’s rating: 95
Kevin says: “I agree with you that they are both amazing and they are both Seattle’s best.”
Kevin’s rating: 94
Finalist
Asadero Prime
Locations: Ballard, Kent
Reviewed on: Episode 118
Tristan says: “Those handmade tortillas: unbelievable. It really is tough to compare it to Tacos Chukis because they’re doing different things, but the combination of flavorful meat plus really flavorful tortillas … that’s what makes me think they’re on the same continuum here.”
Tristan’s rating: 94
Kevin says: “The tacos I had with you slicing up the wagyu from the platter … much better than the actual tacos.”
Kevin’s rating: 93
Semifinalist
El Camion
Locations: Ballard, Aurora, Sodo
Reviewed on: Episode 105
Tristan says: “I feel like the burrito stood out. It’s gigantic. I enjoyed eating almost every single bite of this burrito.”
Tristan’s rating: 92
Kevin says: “I don’t know if the meat was top tier, but the quantity of it and the variety of ways you can get it … I liked all of it.”
Kevin’s rating: 90
Quarterfinalists
Tu Cantinas
Location: Sodo
Reviewed on: Episode 111
Tristan says: “This is my second-highest grade so far.”
Tristan’s rating: 93
Kevin says: “I’m a little lower but maybe if I go all beef and bean, I’ll move it up.”
Kevin’s rating: 90
Taqueria El Gym
Location: Renton
Reviewed on: Episode 112
View this post on Instagram
Yummy Juan’s is now…a gym? Idk what but the California burritos are goood.
Tristan says: “The California burrito is just a good burrito. I enjoyed eating it.”
Tristan’s rating: 92
Kevin says: “I wouldn’t say it was bad the al pastor was marginalized. it was still a tasty burrito.”
Kevin’s rating: 91
The Field
Ambakity Cocina Mexicana
Locations: South Park, Bothell
Reviewed on: Episode 99
Tristan says: “It’s good. It’s just not the best taco in Seattle.”
Tristan’s rating: 85
Kevin says: “I thought the fish tacos were far and away the standout to me.”
Kevin’s rating: 85
Taqueria La Fondita
Location: White Center
Reviewed on: Episode 100
Tristan says: “I think it’s probably the best taco truck that I’ve had in Washington state. Get the $2 burrito.”
Tristan’s rating: 88
Kevin says: “The only time I could go there it was pouring rain, cold and windy. It was not a great experience waiting for the tacos. I feel like if we went back I might have a higher rating.”
Kevin’s rating: 87
Taco Street
Location: Othello
Reviewed on: Episode 101
Tristan says: “The tacos are good, but I don’t think they stand out from food-truck tacos in any way.”
Tristan’s rating: 78
Kevin says: “The consistency of the ingredients was good and there were slices of pineapple in there with the al pastor, which is a huge plus, but the downside was it was very dry.”
Kevin’s rating: 85
El Asadero
Location: Rainier
Reviewed on: Episode 102
Tristan says: “The only negative I can give them is they are cash-only. The combination of the price point, the food itself and being able to order on a bus, you cannot argue with that.”
Tristan’s rating: 90
Kevin says: “The tacos were taco truck tacos. The mulitas were next level.”
Kevin’s rating: 90
Fogon Cocina Mexicana
Location: Capitol Hill
Reviewed on: Episode 103
Tristan says: “It exploded with flavor more than any of the food-truck tacos we’ve had.”
Tristan’s rating: 92
Kevin says: “You walk in the door, and you see the abuela making tortillas, and you know you’re in good hands. I thought the tacos were the best outside of Tacos Chukis we’ve had.”
Kevin’s rating: 92
Taco Time Northwest
Locations: Numerous
Reviewed on: Episode 104
Tristan’s rating: 90
Kevin’s rating: 90
Blue Water Taco Grill
Locations: Several Downtown, Queen Anne, Sodo
Reviewed on: Episode 106
Tristan says: “It’s just fine.”
Tristan’s rating: 80
Kevin says: “In a world where quality burritos are available, it just doesn’t stand out the same way.”
Kevin’s rating: 82
El Burrito Loco
Location: Renton
Reviewed on: Episode 107
Tristan says: “It was kind of just fine. When I’m looking at it with a critical eye, it didn’t meet the muster of what I’d be looking for in the search for Seattle’s best burrito.”
Tristan’s rating: 75
Kevin says: “The meat was just fine. I thought their tortilla was not good, so I would stick to the California burrito.”
Kevin’s rating: 85
Marination
Locations: Alki, Capitol Hill, Denny Triangle
Reviewed on: Episode 108
Tristan says: “I just can’t approach this as a competitor for Seattle’s best taco when it’s not the thing I want most.”
Tristan’s rating: 88
Kevin says: “I thought they were very solid tacos.”
Kevin’s rating: 90
Neon Taco
Locations: Capitol Hill, First Hill
Reviewed on: Episode 109
Tristan says: “It’s not that I dislike it, but the chances of me ever returning are pretty low.”
Tristan’s rating: 85
Kevin says: “If you’re into cloth-napkin tacos, I think you would enjoy it.”
Kevin’s rating: 88
Pecos Pit Barbeque
Location: Sodo
Reviewed on: Episode 110
Tristan says: “When I added the barbeque sauce, it was an explosion of flavor. That took it up 10 points.”
Tristan’s rating: 90
Kevin says: “I think it’s competitive with most non-Tacos Chukis burritos in Seattle.”
Kevin’s rating: 90
Taqueria Cantina
Location: Belltown
Reviewed on: Episode 113
Tristan says: “It just doesn’t pop in any way. There’s no flavor that stands out.”
Tristan’s rating: 80
Kevin says: “It wasn’t a bad experience; I enjoyed my dinner, but I don’t think it’s a contender for Seattle’s best burrito.”
Kevin’s rating: 80
Rancho Bravo Tacos
Locations: Capitol Hill, Federal Way, University District, Wallingford
Reviewed on: Episode 115
Tristan says: “I wouldn’t travel for a Rancho Bravo burrito. It’s just the most average burrito place.”
Tristan’s rating: 75
Kevin says: “I’m not that big a fan of this, so I hadn’t gone back, and I don’t think that take changed, quite frankly.”
Kevin’s rating: 80
Tacos Guaymas
Locations: Capitol Hill, Fremont, Green Lake, Lynnwood, Tacoma
Reviewed on: Episode 116
Tristan says: “You’ve got your Jaliscos, your Toreros, your Aztecas. That, to me, is the family that Tacos Guaymas is in.”
Tristan’s rating: 75
Kevin says: “Quality-wise, I think Guaymas is ahead of them. I disagree with that.”
Kevin’s rating: 85